The Politics of Emotion and the Role of Government

by Whitney Pitcher
NRA Palin

Instead of leaders who offer real solutions, we have leaders who practice the politics of emotion. Now, emotion is a good and necessary thing, but we have politicians exploiting emotion for their own agenda.

[…]

Emotion won’t make anybody safer. Emotion won’t protect the good guys’ rights, and emotion is not leadership. The politics of emotion? It is the opposite of leadership. It is the manipulation of the people by the politicians for their own political ends.

[…]

We have these tragedies like Aurora, and immediately, the question raised in Washington is, “well, what can we do to limit the freedom of the people?” But, it’s the wrong question! The question better asked is, “what can we do to nurture and support a people capable of living in freedom?”

Sarah Palin May 3, 2013

As I listened to Governor Palin’s speech at the NRA-ILA Leadership Forum on Friday, I couldn’t help but think of a quote from Aristotle, “law is reason unaffected by desire”, often stated as “law is reason free from passion”. This is not the kind of “law” that the Left aims to write, however. The Left uses horrific evils like the Newtown shooting to attempt to pass background check laws, when background checks don’t prevent murderers from stealing guns to kill. They ignore areas like Chicago with extremely strict gun control laws, yet high levels of gun crimes and murders, because it does not fit their narrative. The Left believes they know better than the people, and therefore must dictate a set of restrictions and mandates. Aristotle also once noted in his writings that “both oligarch and tyrant mistrust the people, and therefore deprive them of their arms.” Aristotle realized that in order to win a political battle or a revolution, as was the context of the above quote, the oligarchs and tyrants must disarm people. This example isn’t histrionics, nor is it an emotional counterpoint to the Left’s emotion. Instead, it is simply an example of how an over-reaching government can take away constitutionally protected rights by conflating rights with government-determined needs.

Aristotle was a student under Plato, but ultimately became one of Plato’s greatest critics. In his book Ameritopia, Mark Levin provides a good overview of Plato’s book The Republic. Plato’s “republic” is a “utopia” where everything is provided by the Ideal City (i.e. the state), while at the same time, everything is taken by the state (i.e.there is no private property). In the Ideal City, the nuclear family structure is not allowed, eugenics is promoted, and an elitist class system is created. The Guardians, as Plato called them, were the ruling class of philosophers who dictated to the people of the Ideal City. In some ways, the Left wants to pursue a similar “utopia”. As has been highlighted by Melissa Harris-Perry’s recent comments, the Left wants to move away from the concept of family to a concept of children belonging to the community, rather than their partents. Washington has become the new “Guardians”, an elitist class who selectively impose laws on the American people that they themselves do not have to follow. This is the kind of government that Governor Palin warns against.

In her book Going Rogue, Palin wrote:

“At its most basic level conservatism is a respect for history and tradition, including traditional moral principles. I do not believe that I am more moral, certainly no better, than anyone else, and conservatives who act “holier than thou” turn my stomach. So do some elite liberals. But I do believe in a few timeless and unchanging truths, among those is that man is fallen. This world is not perfect, and politicians will never make it so. This, above all, is what informs my pragmatic approach to politics.

[…]

We don’t trust utopian promises from politicians. The role of government is not to perfect us, but to protect us–to protect our inalienable rights. The role of government in a civil society is to protect the individual and to establish a social contract so that we can live together in peace.”

–Governor Sarah Palin
Going Rogue page 385-386 (emphasis added)

The above excerpt helps answer the challenging question that Governor Palin posed in her NRA speech–what can we do to nurture and support a people capable of living in freedom? It is to recognize what government’s (and the Law’s) role is and what government’s role is not. Government’s role is to adhere to the Constitution that protects unalienable rights. Government’s role is not that of a god— a provider or an arbiter of good and evil. A government and a cultural that understands this can help nurture freedom.

1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “The Politics of Emotion and the Role of Government

  1. George Dawson III

    GOV . THANKS AS USUAL FOR GREAT INSIGHT –I READ ALL YOUR BLOGS AND ITS GREAT TO SEE YOU COME OUT FIRING —RIDING HARD AND FAST FOR THE CONSERVATIVE TEA PARTY CONSTITUTIONAL BRAND —THATS COW BOY LADY HAVE A GREAT DAY OH BY THE WAY –LONG AGO I CUT McCAINS NAME OFF OF 08 BUMPER-STICKERS IN THE BACK SIDE WINDOWS OF MY ’74 JEEP CJ-5 AND LEFT YOUR NAME UP –A FUNNY THING HAPPENED IN THE LOCAL RALPHS PARKING LOT HERE IN GLENDALE CALIFORNIA –JUST NORTH OF LOS ANGELES – THE OTHER DAY I CAME OUT OF THE SUPERMARKET AND THIS GUY LOOKED AT ME AND SAID –ARE YOU A TEA PARTY MEMBER –AS USUAL I GRINNED AND WAITED FOR THE INEVITABLE FIGHT —WORDS ONLY OF COURSE –BUT THEN I GOT A SURPRISE HE SAID I THINK WE ARE THE ONLY ONES HERE IN GLENDALE —I IMMEDIATELY TOLD HIM HE WAS MISTAKEN –A LOT OF FOLKS ARE BUT EVEN IN USED TO BE CONSERVATIVE GLENDALE –VERY FEW WILL HAVE YOUR NAME OR THE OLD STICKERS FROM ’08 ON — CASE IN POINT BARELY 2 WEEKS AFTER DER FURHER WON IN ’08 OUR FAMILY CAR WAS KEYED AND DER FURHERS’ NAME WAS WRITTEN ON OUR DOOR !!! YEA THEY ARE SO VERY TOLERANT –I WASNT THERE BUT MY FAMILY TOLD ME WHEN THEY GOT HOME NOW GEORGE ,DADDY DONT GO MARINE COWBOY BUT YOU BETTER LOOK AT THE CAR!!WELL I BLEW UP –LUCKILY FOR THOSE SCUMBAGS I WASNT THERE — ROPES ALWAYS WILL COME IN HANDY ON THE SECOND DECK OF A MALL HA HA BUT THIS IS TO LET YOU KNOW THAT YOU HAVE AGREAT FOLLOWING —ALSO I HAVE YOUR FAMILY PICTURE IN MY COMPUTER WITH THE CAPTION ” THE REAL AMERICAN FIRST FAMILY “– BUY THE WAY IM LAZY —ONLY WHEN I TYPE –NO OTHER TIME —I ALWAYS USE UPPER CASE YES I CATCH FLACK BUT I DONT CARE I JUST TELL THEM TO GO READ DER FURHER S B.S. IF THEY DONT LIKE MY TYPING ANYWAY THANKS FOR BEING TRUE TO THE ” REPUBLICAN BRAND ” ILL CLOSE THIS DISERTATION THE WAY I ALWAYS CLOSE

    GODS WARRIOR SERVANT AND YOURS SWG GEORGE G-1 O-2 I-3

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s